“He was afraid of nothing. Until he’d met me.”
The romance genre stands out as one of the most popular in the world of reading, broadly categorized into two types: open-door and closed-door. Knowing the differences between open-door romance and closed-door romance is a fundamental piece of knowledge to have if you’re an avid reader of the genre or a budding writer in it. Join us at What We Reading as we take you through everything you need to know about open-door romance books, what makes them different from closed-door reads, as well as some great examples to dive in with.
What Does Open-Door Romance Mean In Books?
Open-door romance books contain explicit and adult material. These scenes are spicy, with detailed descriptions of what happens between characters that would be considered ‘private.’ Because of this, books in this category tend to come with an age rating of 18+ or various trigger warnings for readers.
What Does Closed-Door Romance Mean In Books?
Opposed to open-door romance, closed-door romance books have no intimate or explicit scenes. As the name suggests, all the spicy material is kept ‘behind closed doors.’ This is either due to the author’s decision to keep things PG or because these types of scenes do not exist in the plot.
Check Out All You Need To Know About Closed-Door Romance
What Does Closed-Door Modification Mean?
Closed-door modification refers to knowing which chapters in a book contain steamy or explicit material and skipping them. By avoiding reading these sections, a reader is adapting an open-door romance novel into a closed-door book.
Open And Closed-Door Romance Books: Why It Matters
Set Reader Expectations
Not every romance reader wants to read explicit material. For some readers, the enjoyment of a clean romantic read is sufficient, featuring lighthearted flirting and minimal physical contact as described by the author.
For others, having a steamy scene or two is all a part of the fun or a suitable pay-off for two characters whose energies have converged to that point.
Whichever you prefer, there’s no superior approach in the closed vs open-door romance debate. Readers have the right to read whatever they want, which is why labelling your book with either an ‘open’ or ‘closed door’ tag can be so beneficial in adjusting their expectations for what’s to come.
Determine Age Ratings
Labels such as open and closed-door romance novels help set appropriate age ratings for your books. As well as helping set reader expectations, these labels also help ensure younger readers don’t stumble upon material not suitable for them.
How To Modify An Open Romance Book To Closed-Door
The best way to modify an open-door romance novel into a closed-door one is by searching online for chapters or segments with explicit material. Many book reviews or summaries will include anecdotes for readers to use, enabling them to skip over the most intimate parts and turn the book into a closed-door romance.
Examples Of Open-Door Romance Novels
Here are some excellent examples of open-door romance books, along with the reasons they have earned this label:
- Fifty Shades Of Grey – E.L. James
- Why It’s Open Door: Infamous for its explicit content between main characters Anastasia Steele and Christian Grey. Author E.L. James doesn’t shy away from describing their physical relationship in detail.
- Bared To You – Sylvia Day
- Why It’s Open Door: Similar to Fifty Shades of Grey, Sylvia Day’s Bared to You is considered open-door thanks to its explicit content. The opening book in The Crossfire series chronicles the intense relationship between protagonists Gideon Cross and Eva Tramell.
- Beautiful Disaster – Jamie McGuire
- Why It’s Open Door: Beautiful Disaster gives readers a detailed insight into the tumultuous relationship between Travis Maddox and Abby Abernathy, including scenes of their physical intimacy.
- Dirty Rowdy Thing – Christina Lauren
- Why It’s Open Door: Christina Lauren lift the lid on the steamy moments between Finn Roberts and Harlow Vega in Dirty Rowdy Thing. Christina Lauren are authors known for their frank and open portrayals of romance in their books.
- Thoughtless – S.C. Stephens
- Why It’s Open Door: In Thoughtless, readers are shown every part of the complicated love triangle between Kiera Allen, Denny Harris, and Kellan Kyle. The open door label comes from the detailed and explicit scenes that show the complexities of this dynamic.
Wrap Up
Open-door romance books are perfect for readers who are looking for a little bit more spice from their books. These stories are still very much in trend and still come with the emotional connections needed to build a believable and compelling love story. The key difference is how the author follows these characters into the areas that would normally be off-limits.
As mentioned above, there is no superior or ‘better’ way of reading romance novels – go with what you enjoy and what you’re in the mood for! Having said that, readers always have the option to modify an open-door romance story into a closed-door one by looking up the detailed or explicit material in a book and skipping over it.
Part-time reader, part-time rambler, and full-time Horror enthusiast, James has been writing for What We Reading since 2022. His earliest reading memories involved Historical Fiction, Fantasy and Horror tales, which he has continued to take with him to this day. James’ favourite books include The Last (Hanna Jameson), The Troop (Nick Cutter) and Chasing The Boogeyman (Richard Chizmar).
