“Sometimes you hate someone so much, you fall in love.”
When it comes to matters of the heart, it is often said that opposites attract. Not only are there more things to discover, understand, and learn to appreciate, but it’s only natural to feel drawn to individuals who possess skills, passions, or characteristics that you either want, need, or admire. With that being said, dealing so intimately with someone who appears to be your polar opposite can also be responsible for inducing some of the most fiery emotions you’re able to conjure up. It’s a fine tightrope to walk.
The dynamic of two contrasting characters and the classic ‘will they/won’t they’ scenario has led to many different tropes in the literary world, with the ‘sunshine/grumpy’ label being one of the most commonly assigned. Join us today at What We Reading as we explore the grumpy/sunshine trope and what makes it so popular with romance readers!
What Is The Grumpy/Sunshine Trope?
The grumpy/sunshine trope is pretty self-explanatory: two characters with conflicting personalities meet. One of the characters is bubbly, exuberant, and upbeat, while the other is dreary, cynical, and pessimistic. While their differences might initially cause some conflict, they gradually begin to realize they have a connection.
The competition between the opposites usually leads to plenty of good-value quips, remarks, and comebacks, with readers getting an inside look at how both parties realize they are falling in love.
Why Are Grumpy/Sunshine Books Popular?
As mentioned briefly above, having characters that are different from each other not only gives them personalities of their own but also makes them more nuanced and interesting to read.
There are a plethora of ways to pull off this book trope as well, making it appealing for writers who want to flex their ways of writing romance. Grumpy/Sunshine tropes can extend across any mood or tone, for example, a fun and lighthearted read full of wisecracks and flirtation, or a profoundly moving story exploring deeper, sometimes heavier themes.
Ultimately, the trope allows for characters to fall for each other for who they are and be seen by their partner as themselves, rather than having to change their appearance or personality.
Problems With The Trope
Despite the enduring popularity of grumpy/sunshine romance books, some criticisms have emerged across the reading world regarding the gender dynamics imposed by certain stories. The majority of these books centre around a male-identifying character assuming the role of the ‘grumpy hero’, while the sunshine role is often reserved for female-identifying characters.
Readers have commented on whether these roles reflect our collective socialization, questioning if audiences are content seeing women consistently perky and spreading joy while rarely expressing disappointments or issues of their own.
Critiques have also surfaced regarding the portrayal of naive sunshine characters and the miraculous transformation of ‘stuck-in-the-mud’ grumpy characters solely through the power of love.
Nevertheless, as the romance genre has evolved, so too have the representations of grumpy/sunshine tropes. An increasing number of male-identifying characters have been given the ‘sunshine’ role, while female protagonists have received more nuanced personalities, fleshing out the ‘grumpy’ trope.
Furthermore, the growing representation of LGBTQ+ characters and relationships has played a role in pushing the trope into new dimensions.
Examples Of Grumpy/Sunshine Romance Books
To help you get better acquainted with this trope, here are some examples of grumpy/sunshine books, and the dynamics that give them this tag:
- The Hating Game – Sally Thorne
- Sunshine: Lucy Hutton is the cheerful and quirky protagonist.
- Grumpy: Joshua Templeman, her co-worker, is the cynical and more serious character.
- Dynamic: Their workplace rivalry and banter turn into a complicated love-hate relationship.
- Beach Read – Emily Henry
- Sunshine: January Andrews is a cheery romance writer.
- Grumpy: Augustus Everett is a cynical literary fiction author.
- Dynamic: The pair switch genres for a summer, leading to a series of unexpected changes in both their professional, and personal, lives.
- The Wall Of Winnipeg And Me – Mariana Zapata
- Sunshine: Aiden Graves, a professional football player, is cheerful and carefree.
- Grumpy: Vanessa Mazur is a more guarded personal assistant.
- Dynamic: A slow-burn romance grows as Aiden works to win Vanessa over, leading to them growing from confidants to friends, to something more.
- The Charm Offensive – Alison Cochrun
- Sunshine: Dev Deshpande is a successful TV producer renowned for producing perfect love-story scripts.
- Grumpy: Charlie Winshaw is a stiff, anxious mess with very few social skills when it comes to dating.
- Dynamic: As the pair attempt to work together on their reality TV dating show, they begin to confide in one another, leading to some off-script connections.
- Well Met – Jen DeLuca
- Sunshine: Emily is a quirky English teacher with a positive attitude.
- Grumpy: Simon, the Renaissance Faire organizer, is initially strict and inscrutable.
- Dynamic: Their rivalry and lighthearted flirty within the Faire setting create an unexpected and tension-filled romance.
Part-time reader, part-time rambler, and full-time Horror enthusiast, James has been writing for What We Reading since 2022. His earliest reading memories involved Historical Fiction, Fantasy and Horror tales, which he has continued to take with him to this day. James’ favourite books include The Last (Hanna Jameson), The Troop (Nick Cutter) and Chasing The Boogeyman (Richard Chizmar).
